Replacing your kitchen countertops is a great way to update the look and feel of your kitchen. It can also improve the functionality and durability of your culinary workspace. But with so many different countertop materials and options available, it can be tough to know where to start.

In this blog, we’re leaning on our decades of experience to provide you with five things to consider when replacing your kitchen countertops.

1. Materials

There are a wide variety of countertop materials available you can use in your kitchen remodel, each with its own unique advantages and disadvantages. Some of the most popular countertop materials include:

• Granite: Granite is durable and resistant to heat and scratches. While relatively low-maintenance, it requires periodic sealing to maintain its resistance to stains.
• Quartz: Quartz offers a non-porous surface, making it resistant to stains and easy to clean, but exposure to excessive heat may cause damage. 
• Marble: Marble brings timeless elegance to kitchens and offers heat resistance, but is susceptible to scratching and etching from acidic substances. 
• Butcher block: Butcher block exudes warmth and charm with its natural wood appeal, but requires regular sealing to prevent damage from moisture and may show scratches and dings over time.
• Laminate: Laminate is an affordable countertop solution that is resistant to stains, but is susceptible to almost irreparable scratches and heat damage.
• Concrete: Concrete provides a sleek and customizable surface for kitchens, but may require regular sealing to prevent staining and is prone to hairline cracks over time.

2. Costs

There are numerous costs associated with countertop replacement that you should be aware of before starting your renovation project. They include the following:

Material costs

The type of material you choose for your kitchen countertop will impact the overall cost of replacement. Here’s what you can expect to pay for different countertop materials:

• Granite: $65 – $215 /sq ft installed
• Quartz: $65 – $185 /sq ft installed
• Marble: $40 – $220 /sq ft installed
• Butcher block: $50 – $150 /sq ft installed
• Laminate: $20 – $80 /sq ft installed
• Concrete: $80 – $155 /sq ft installed

Keep in mind that these are general estimates, and prices can vary based on factors such as brand, location, and the complexity of the installation.

Additional features

Beyond the basic material and installation costs, additional features you might want to incorporate can add to your costs. Be prepared to pay more for special edge profiles, backsplashes, or unique design elements. 

Removal and disposal costs

Be sure to account for costs associated with removing and disposing of existing countertops. This involves safely dismantling and disposing of the old countertop material. The complexity of this process can impact how much you’ll have to spend. 

DIY vs. professional installation

You can save money on installation costs by doing some (or even all) of the work yourself. However, complex materials like granite or quartz can be tricky to handle, necessitating the touch of professionals. Beware, if the countertop material is damaged or the installation is subpar, it may require replacement, incurring additional expenses.

3. Lifestyle and usage

Your kitchen countertop isn’t just met for show, it’s a central hub for all your culinary escapades and daily activities. When selecting your materials, consider your lifestyle and how you’ll use your countertop. If you’re an avid chef or culinary enthusiast then be sure to select materials like granite or quartz that can handle the heat and are very low maintenance. 

If your kitchen is a space for entertaining guests, you’ll want a countertop that looks good and performs well. Consider materials like marble or butcher block. Marble’s elegant appearance adds a touch of sophistication to your space. Butcher block, with its warm and natural appeal, is perfect for creating a cozy atmosphere and is ideal for serving as a buffet or casual dining space.

Some kitchens are more laid-back, where cooking is a pleasure but not a constant activity. For such environments, materials like laminate can be practical choices. Laminate offers an array of colors and patterns, allowing you to achieve the desired aesthetic without breaking the bank. 

4. Color palette and aesthetic appeal

The color and design of your countertop help define the overall aesthetic of your kitchen. When choosing your replacement countertops, consider the color palette and style of your kitchen when the renovation is complete. Whether you opt for classic neutrals, bold statement hues, or intricate patterns, ensure that your new countertop harmonizes with the existing decor.

Color palette

Here are some tips for choosing a countertop color palette:

• Consider the overall style of your kitchen. If you have a traditional kitchen, you may want to choose a classic neutral color like white, beige, or gray. If you have a modern kitchen, you may want to choose a bolder color like black, red, or blue.
• Consider the other colors in your kitchen. The countertop should complement the other colors in your kitchen, such as the cabinets, appliances, and backsplash.
• Think about the amount of natural light in your kitchen. If you have a lot of natural light, you can get away with choosing a darker color. If you have a darker kitchen, you may want to choose a lighter color to brighten up the space.

Aesthetic appeal

In addition to color, there are a few other factors to consider when choosing a countertop for its aesthetic appeal:

• Pattern: Some countertop materials, such as granite and marble, have natural patterns that can add visual interest to your kitchen. If you choose a patterned countertop, be sure to choose a pattern that you love and that will complement the other elements in your kitchen.
• Finish: Countertop finishes can range from polished to honed to leathered. The finish you choose will affect the overall look and feel of your countertop. For example, a polished finish will give your countertop a sleek and modern look, while a honed finish will give it a more rustic appearance.
• Edge profile: The edge profile can impact the overall look and feel. Beveled edges offer a classic touch, while bullnose edges provide a smooth, rounded finish. Explore various edge profiles to find the one that complements your design preferences and adds that perfect finishing touch.

5. Seamless integration

A well-executed installation can enhance both the visual appeal and functionality of your kitchen, while a poorly executed installation can lead to problems such as visible seams, leaks, and cracks. Here are some tips for seamlessly integrating a new countertop into your kitchen.

• Choose a qualified contractor. Countertop installation can be a complex process, so it’s important to hire a qualified contractor. Be sure to get multiple estimates and read reviews before hiring a professional.
• Discuss your layout and designer. Before the installation begins, discuss your layout and design with your contractor. This will help reduce visible seams and ensure that your new countertops are installed to your liking, minimizing costly rework.
• Consider the type of countertop material. Some countertop materials, such as quartz and granite, can be more easily seamed than others. If you’re concerned, be sure to choose a material that can be seamed well.
• Use a color-matched sealant. Once your countertops are installed, use a color-matched sealant to conceal any visible seams. This will help to create a polished look.

Auros—experienced remodel professionals

Whether you’re looking to replace your countertops or completely strip your kitchen down to the studs and remodel it completely, you can turn to us for unparalleled expertise and superior results. Trust our creative designers and team of professional contractors to transform your kitchen with confidence—making your dream kitchen a reality.

Get started by scheduling your free in-home design consultation today!